Alerts

An Israeli Jerusalem for All

Underlying the post-Camp David debate over Jerusalem is a fundamentally disturbing assumption that Jerusalem cannot possibly remain united under the sovereignty of the Jewish state, but instead must somehow be shared. Strikingly, this notion of sharing holy cities has not been applied to other cases in the international community...
Share this

Table of Contents

New York Jewish Week

Underlying the post-Camp David debate over Jerusalem is a fundamentally disturbing assumption that Jerusalem cannot possibly remain united under the sovereignty of the Jewish state, but instead must somehow be shared. Strikingly, this notion of sharing holy cities has not been applied to other cases in the international community: not to Istanbul, where Greek Orthodox have a special attachment; not to Mecca, where the Shiites and other branches of Islam have feared the ultra-Orthodox control of the Wahhabi sect in Saudi Arabia; or in any other case where there has been struggle over sovereignty and religious freedom.

Ironically, prior to Israel’s liberation of Jerusalem in 1967, Jerusalem was not open to all faiths. Transjordan’s Arab Legion, manned with British officers, destroyed or desecrated more than 50 synagogues in Jerusalem’s Old City as it fell, expelled its Jewish residents and for nearly 20 years prevented Jews of any nationality from praying at the Western Wall. Synagogues, notably the Yohanan Ben Zakai complex, were converted into stables. Thousands of tombstones from the ancient Jewish cemetery on the Mount of Olives were uprooted, and even used for latrines. During that time eastern Jerusalem’s Christian population dwindled from 25,000 to 11,000.

The United Nations, whose nonbinding recommendation first proposed an internationalized Jerusalem in General Assembly Resolution 181 of 1947, did nothing when Jerusalem was invaded and put under siege during Israel’s 1948 War of Independence. Only the convoys of the nascent Israeli army protected the city’s encircled Jewish residents. For the next 20 years, the great powers sitting on the UN Security Council were silent over the lack of religious freedom in eastern Jerusalem. The hypocrisy over the Jerusalem question became evident when the Security Council finally became activated only after Israeli forces recaptured the Old City in the Six-Day War.

Did Muslims lose access when the Jews took control? In fact, while Israel asserted sovereignty over the Old City in 1967, Defense Minister Moshe Dayan made sure that the Muslim holy sites on the Temple Mount remained under the control of Muslim authorities appointed by Jordan. This practice of Muslim administration has continued even as Palestinians have replaced Jordanians. Muslims from Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon and even Libya pray in the al-Aqsa mosque. In the clash of civilizations in Spain or India, vanquished Muslim holy sites became churches or temples, but not in the Old City of Jerusalem under the sovereignty of the Jewish state.

Perhaps the driving forces for a shared Jerusalem are the national claims of the Palestinians. But, in fact, the Jewish people re-established a majority in Jerusalem by the mid-19th century, according to the British consul general at the time, well before the rise of modern Zionism. That majority remains intact in united Jerusalem.

Sovereignty over Jerusalem once rested with the Ottoman Empire, but the latter relinquished its claims just after World War I. The historical rights of the Jewish people to Jerusalem and Palestine were recognized by the League of Nations and inherited by its successor organization, the United Nations, under Article 80 of the UN Charter. Security Council Resolution 242, which is the basis of the Madrid and Oslo processes, requires an Israeli withdrawal from “territories” but does not mandate Israel to concede Jerusalem, which the resolution does not even mention.

Thus, the fact that the demand for sharing a holy city, like Jerusalem, is applied only to the case of Israel is based on a fundamental discomfort with the deeper implications of Jewish sovereignty. This indeed was the position of the early Church, which banned Jews from residing in Jerusalem for centuries. It sensed vindication at the yearly scene of Jews “wailing” at the remains of the Temple, whose destruction was seen as proof of their punishment for not accepting Christianity. This view has since been repudiated by Pope John Paul II, who visited Jerusalem under Israeli sovereignty in March.

What, then, is bothering the advocates of a shared Jerusalem? In 1967, the liberation of Jerusalem led to a worldwide rebirth of Jewish identity. The recapture of the Old City awakened a whole generation of modern Maccabees in the former Soviet Union, like Natan Sharansky, who stood up to a totalitarian superpower. And to millions of American Jews, a liberated Jerusalem became a counterweight to the powerful forces of assimilation, for it tied modern Israel to the traditions of ancient Israel. In Israel, it rekindled the Zionist spirit. The opponents of this reinvigorated Jewish identity, and the national self-confidence that it generated, are also the opponents of Israel remaining sovereign in Jerusalem.

In modern times the Jewish people have in fact been pulled between two poles: universalism and particularism. In Jerusalem, the two poles coexist. For in protecting the rights of the Jewish state in Jerusalem, Israel can accomplish its universalistic mission of protecting the rights of other faiths as well. That is what having a Jewish state is all about. Israel does not protect Jerusalem by a policy of self-denial, but rather by confirming its own national rights and extending a hand of religious tolerance and coexistence that was never demonstrated by Jerusalem’s previous masters.

Dore Gold served as Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations from 1997 to 1999.

Amb. Dore Gold

Ambassador Dore Gold has served as President of the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs since 2000. From June 2015 until October 2016 he served as Director-General of the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs. Previously he served as Foreign Policy Advisor to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel’s Ambassador to the UN (1997-1999), and as an advisor to Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.
Share this

Subscribe to Daily Alert

The Daily Alert – Israel news digest appears every Sunday, Tuesday, and Thursday.

Related Items

Stay Informed, Always

Get the latest news, insights, and updates directly in your inbox—be the first to know!

Subscribe to Jerusalem Issue Briefs
The Daily Alert – Israel news digest appears every Sunday, Tuesday, and Thursday.







Notifications

The Jerusalem Center
What makes a child believe killing a #Jew is justified?

In PA textbooks, Jews are called liars and frauds; their fate: elimination. This is #indoctrination—not #education. But change is happening. On East to West, @IMPACT_SE CEO Marcus Sheff exposes how #UNRWA-funded schools are fueling extremism—and what real reform looks like.  Listen now on Spotify: open.spotify.com/show/2JHqh973U  Watch on YouTube: youtu.be/8OkJTGNfVUc

11:43am
The Jerusalem Center
Highlights from the @Jerusalem_Post Annual Conference in NYC:

Dr. @Dan_Diker, President of the JCFA: “October 7 wasn’t just an attack on Israel — it was a blow to the U.S. on Israeli soil. It demands moral clarity and a united front between Israel and the U.S. to defeat jihadist terror.”

2:20pm
The Jerusalem Center
@XAVIAERD says it like it is

Well, @XAVIAERD says it like it is: If you’re part of “#Queers for #Palestine,” he’ll pay for your flight to #Gaza. Go see for yourself how they treat LGBTQ+ people over there. Don’t miss this bold take on the Israel-Hamas war and the woke right.

2:32pm
The Jerusalem Center
“This isn’t Israel vs. Hamas — it’s the frontline of the free world.”

“This isn’t Israel vs. Hamas — it’s the frontline of the free world.” On Our Middle East by @JNS_org, @Dan_Diker@KhaledAbuToameh (JCFA/@GatestoneInst) break it down: If Hamas isn’t crushed, Iran wins. The jihadis—from #Gaza to your campus—get the green light. Diker: “This war is for the West.” No fluff. No filters. Just raw insight from two insiders who actually know what’s going on.  Watch: youtu.be/4Aq_zcbb4Yo

2:15pm
The Jerusalem Center
5/5 Lt. Col. Kalo on East to West with @smartinezamir:

“This operation showcases Israel’s strategic intelligence superiority both regionally and globally. It demonstrates the moral commitment to recovered soldiers and also strengthens Israel’s position with allies.” youtube.com/watch?v=nIvNNi

2:07pm
The Jerusalem Center
4/5 The operation built on intelligence gathered during the 2019 #Baumel recovery

#Mossad agents operated under cover in #Syria for years, visiting a graveyard multiple times under fire to collect remains for DNA matching. The intelligence community’s evolution combines technology, big data analysis, and human intelligence capabilities.

2:02pm
The Jerusalem Center
3/5 This recovery coincided with the release of Israeli hostage Edan Alexander

This recovery coincided with the release of Israeli hostage Edan Alexander from #Hamas in #Gaza, significantly boosting national morale amid an ongoing conflict now stretching over 18 months. The dual successes demonstrate #Israel‘s unwavering commitment to bringing all soldiers home.

1:58pm
The Jerusalem Center
2/5 The operation used the power vacuum following #Assad’s fall from #Damascus

Lt. Col. Avi Kalo, former head of IDF Prisoners & Missing Persons Division, calls it “an outstanding event that brings hope and new spirit to the people of Israel.” The operation utilized the power vacuum following #Assad‘s fall from #Damascus, allowing #Israeli intelligence to deploy ground capabilities in #Syria.

1:56pm
The Jerusalem Center
1/5 Israeli forces recovered the remains of Sergeant First Class Zvi Feldman

In an unprecedented operation, Israeli forces have recovered the remains of Sergeant First Class Zvi #Feldman, missing since the 1982 Battle of Sultan Yacoub. The complex #Mossad mission was conducted deep within #Syrian territory, 43 years after his disappearance. This follows the successful 2019 recovery of Zachary #Baumel from the same battle.

1:54pm
The Jerusalem Center
A molotov attack on a bus = a “barbecue party”?

That’s what #Palestinian kids are being taught under @UNRWA  — from grade school to graduation. This isn’t education. It’s indoctrination. Marcus Sheff of @IMPACT_SE  breaks it down with @smartinezamir

12:51pm

Close